Accuracy of regional-to-global soil maps for on-farm decision making: Are soil maps good enough?

Authors: MAYNARD, JONATHAN - University Of Colorado; YEBOAH, EDWARD - Csir-Crops Research Institute; OWUSU, STEVEN - Csir-Crops Research Institute; BUENEMANN, MICHAELA - New Mexico State University; NEFF, JASON - University Of Colorado; Herrick, Jeffrey

Submitted to: Soil
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal
Publication Acceptance Date: 3/27/2023
Publication Date: 5/26/2023
Citation: Maynard, J.J., Yeboah, E., Owusu, S., Buenemann, M., Neff, J.C., Herrick, J.E. 2023. Accuracy of regional-to-global soil maps for on-farm decision making: Are soil maps good enough?. Soil. 9:277-300. https://doi.org/10.5194/soil-9-277-2023.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/soil-9-277-2023

Interpretive Summary: Soil maps are often accepted as "truth". The reality is that soil maps are simply predictions of the soils, and soil properties, occurring at a particular location. Most traditional soil maps are actually maps of groups of soils that occur together within map units, while the newer "digital" soil maps use statistical methods to predict soil properties for each pixel. The accuracy of the predictions, varies widely across the globe and, is poorly understood. Even less well understood is whether the accuracy is high enough to use the prediction to make a decision, without digging a hole to confirm soil type. . The main objective of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of four soil maps currently in use in Ghana using a collection of 6,959 soil profile descriptions recorded using the LandPKS mobile application. Results from this study revealed that current soil maps in Ghana, while often effective for larger-scale analyses, lack the needed accuracy to reliably inform soil management decisions at the farm-scale.

Technical Abstract: A major obstacle to selecting the most appropriate crops and closing the yield gap in many areas of the world is a lack of site-specific soil information. Accurate information on soil properties is critical for identifying soil limitations and the management practices needed to improve crop yields. However, acquiring accurate soil information is often difficult due to the high spatial and temporal variability of soil properties at fine scales and the cost and inaccessibility of laboratory-based soil analyses. With recent advancements in predictive soil mapping, there is a growing expectation that soil map predictions can provide much of the information needed to inform soil management. Yet, it is unclear how accurate current soil map predictions are at scales relevant to management. The main objective of this study was to address this issue by evaluating the site-specific accuracy of regional-to-global soil maps, using Ghana as a test case. Four web-based soil maps of Ghana were evaluated using a dataset of 6514 soil profile descriptions collected on smallholder farms using the LandPKS mobile application. Results from this study revealed that publicly available soil maps in Ghana lack the needed accuracy (i.e., correct identification of soil limitations) to reliably inform soil management decisions at the 1–2'ha scale common to smallholders. Standard measures of map accuracy for soil texture class and rock fragment class predictions showed that all soil maps had similar performance in estimating the correct property class. Overall soil texture class accuracies ranged from 8'%–14'% but could be as high as 38'%–64'% after accounting for uncertainty in the evaluation dataset. Soil rock fragment class accuracies ranged from 26'%–29'%. However, despite these similar overall accuracies, there were substantial differences in soil property predictions among the four maps, highlighting that soil map errors are not uniform between maps. To better understand the functional implications of these soil property differences, we used a modified version of the FAO Global Agro-Ecological Zone (GAEZ) soil suitability modeling framework to derive soil suitability ratings for each soil data source. Using a low-input, rain-fed, maize production scenario, we evaluated the functional accuracy of map-based soil property estimates. This analysis showed that soil map data significantly overestimated crop suitability for over 65'% of study sites, potentially leading to ineffective agronomic investments by farmers, including cash-constrained smallholders.