Location: Geospatial and Environmental Epidemiology Research Unit
Title: Noninferiority of cycle threshold values from 0.9% sterile saline compared with PBS as a collection medium for Tritrichomonas foetus RT-rtPCR testingAuthor
![]() |
JUMPER, TYLER - Mississippi State University |
![]() |
THORESEN, MERRILEE - Mississippi State University |
![]() |
KING, E - Mississippi State University |
![]() |
LOY, DUAN - Mississippi State University |
![]() |
LOY, JOHN - Mississippi State University |
![]() |
SMITH, DAVID - Mississippi State University |
|
Submitted to: Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigation
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal Publication Acceptance Date: 12/2/2025 Publication Date: 2/7/2026 Citation: Jumper, T.M., Thoresen, M., King, E.H., Loy, D.S., Loy, J.D., Smith, D.R. 2026. Noninferiority of cycle threshold values from 0.9% sterile saline compared with PBS as a collection medium for Tritrichomonas foetus RT-rtPCR testing. Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigation. 38(3). https://doi.org/10.1177/10406387261418210. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/10406387261418210 Interpretive Summary: This study evaluated whether sterile saline performs as well as PBS as a transport medium for samples tested by RT rtPCR for T. foetus. Samples were prepared with varying concentrations of the organism. Concentration levels significantly affected Ct values, but the choice of medium did not. The normalized Ct averages for saline and PBS were statistically comparable, showing that saline is noninferior to PBS. Using saline could reduce costs and simplify logistics without compromising test reliability. Technical Abstract: Tritrichomonas foetus infection can cause reproductive losses and subsequent economic losses in cow-calf herds. Our objective was to determine if 0.9% sterile saline (saline) was noninferior to PBS as a transport medium for T. foetus reverse-transcription real-time PCR (RT-rtPCR) testing. Transport tubes were prepared with either 1.6 mL of PBS with preputial washing (n = 30) or 1.6 mL of saline with preputial washing (n = 30) and inoculated at 3 different concentrations of T. foetus organisms (high = 100 org/100 µL; moderate = 10 org/100 µL; low = 1 org/100 µL) for a total volume of 1.7 mL/ tube. Samples were submitted to a diagnostic laboratory for RT-rtPCR analysis. The effect of concentration and medium on mean Ct values was tested using linear regression. Normalized means were used to conduct a noninferiority t-test, with a noninferiority margin of 1 Ct. For all analyses, a = 0.05. Mean Ct values (high = 18.5; moderate = 22.7; low = 30.4) differed by concentration (p <0.0001), whereas medium (p = 0.67) and the interaction of medium and concentration (p = 0.87) were not significant. The normalized mean Ct for PBS was 22.6 (min = 16.2; max = 27.0), and for saline was 22.8 (min = 20.9; max = 26.4). The normalized mean Ct of saline was noninferior to PBS (p = 0.037). The use of saline as a transport medium for T. foetus RT-rtPCR should not affect Ct results. |
