Location: Water Quality and Ecology Research
Title: Redfield revisited: insights into seston C:N:P stoichiometry in freshwater ecosystemsAuthor
![]() |
ANDERSON, ISABELLE - Baylor University |
![]() |
Taylor, Jason |
![]() |
GRAEBER, DANIEL - Helmholtz Centre For Environmental Research |
![]() |
KELLY, PATRICK - Wisconsin Department Of Natural Resources |
![]() |
HOKE, ALEXA - Baylor University |
![]() |
ROBBINS, CALEB - Baylor University |
![]() |
SCOTT, JEFFERSON - Baylor University |
|
Submitted to: Limnology and Oceanography Journal
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal Publication Acceptance Date: 6/24/2025 Publication Date: 7/12/2025 Citation: Anderson, I.M., Taylor, J.M., Graeber, D., Kelly, P.T., Hoke, A.K., Robbins, C.J., Scott, J.T. 2025. Redfield revisited: insights into seston C:N:P stoichiometry in freshwater ecosystems. Limnology and Oceanography Journal. https://doi.org/10.1002/lno.70133. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/lno.70133 Interpretive Summary: Excess nutrients from industrial, municipal, and agricultural runoff can impact health of freshwater and coastal ecosystems. This limits important ecological services provided by these habitats including drinking water, commercial fisheries, and recreational opportunities for the American people. A key consideration in identifying which nutrients need to be managed to reduce impacts is understanding the influence of the relative ratios of key nutrients including carbon (C), nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) on the regulation of algae blooms. Most monitoring and restoration programs recognize a long-held assumption that the C:N:P ratio of 106:16:1 represents optimal conditions for algal growth. Results from a long-term replicated pond experiment conducted by USDA-ARS scientists and research partners challenges this assumption and suggests managers should consider a broader range of optimal ratios when considering management targets for nutrients designed to reduce impacts of enrichment on freshwater and coastal ecosystems. Technical Abstract: Seston carbon (C), nitrogen (N), and phosphorous (P) stoichiometry plays a fundamental role in aquatic ecosystems, influencing nutrient cycling, primary and secondary production, and trophic interactions. In marine systems, N often limits primary production, whereas freshwater ecosystems are more commonly P-limited, reflecting distinct nutrient limitation statuses across aquatic environments. The Redfield ratio (C106:N16:P1 molar), developed from marine seston, has long been considered a benchmark for nutrient composition and a predictor of N and P limitation across aquatic ecosystems. A later global marine and freshwater seston survey proposed the Sterner ratio (C166:N20:P1 molar) as a broader global seston average. Here we present the results of a fully replicated, multi-annual mesocosm experiment testing the effect of variable resource N:P stoichiometry on seston stoichiometry. We found that the seston C:N:P ratio aligned with the Redfield ratio under N-limited conditions while P-limited conditions aligned with a global survey of freshwater ecosystems. Ternary plots offered visual insight into stoichiometric shifts, showing a trend toward P depletion relative to C and N as N:P supply increases. The average seston C:N:P ratio observed from our experimental data was C141:N22:P1 (molar) and variation in seston C:N:P was small compared to the resource ratio gradient. Our mesocosm experiment showed that the Redfield ratio provides a useful description of seston stoichiometry in strictly N-limited freshwater ecosystems. These findings advance the understanding of bottom-up controls on seston C:N:P stoichiometry and draw attention to the need to refine ecological theories regarding the application of the Redfield ratio to freshwater ecosystems. |
