Author
WANG, YI - University Of Idaho | |
SNODGRASS, LANCE - University Of Wisconsin | |
Bethke, Paul | |
BUSSAN, ALVIN - Wysocki Produce Farm Inc | |
HOLM, DAVID - Colorado State University | |
Novy, Richard | |
PAVEK, MARK - Washington State University | |
PORTER, GREGORY - University Of Maine | |
ROSEN, CARL - University Of Minnesota | |
SATHUVALLI, VIDYASAGAR - Oregon State University | |
THOMPSON, ASUNTA - North Dakota State University | |
THORNTON, MICHAEL - University Of Idaho | |
ENDELMAN, JEFFREY - University Of Wisconsin |
Submitted to: Crop Science
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal Publication Acceptance Date: 2/27/2017 Publication Date: 3/13/2017 Publication URL: https://handle.nal.usda.gov/10113/5801875 Citation: Wang, Y., Snodgrass, L.B., Bethke, P.C., Bussan, A.J., Holm, D.G., Novy, R.G., Pavek, M.J., Porter, G.A., Rosen, C.J., Sathuvalli, V., Thompson, A.L., Thornton, M.T., Endelman, J.B. 2017. Reliability of measurement and genotype x environment interaction for potato specific gravity. Crop Science. 57(4):1966-1972. doi: 10.2135/cropsci2016.12.0976. Interpretive Summary: The dry matter content of potatoes used to make potato chips and French fries strongly influences fry oil absorption and texture of the finished product and is therefore an important trait to the potato processing industry. Tuber specific gravity, a measure of tuber density relative to the density of water, is often used to assess the quality of chip and fry processing potatoes because it is strongly correlated with dry mater content and is easy to measure. For French fry processing varieties, the desirable range for mean specific gravity is 1.080–1.095 and little variability around the mean is essential for product uniformity. The reliability of potato specific gravity measurements was evaluated using potatoes from two multi-site, multi-year trials. Mean specific gravity measurements were highly repeatable, but the repeatability of the variation around the mean was low. Thus, large multi-environment trials are required in order to identify new varieties with the narrow specific gravity distribution desired by potato processors. These findings provide guidance to potato breeders and agronomists who conduct evaluations of potential new fry processing varieties on how best to identify varieties with superior tuber characteristics with respect to specific gravity. Comparisons between production environments showed a consistent regional pattern in mean specific gravity over time. There was a higher correlation in mean specific gravity between locations within the Pacific Northwest, Upper Midwest, and Northeast than between environments from different regions. Although breeding new varieties for nationwide production is an attractive idea, our results suggest that genetic improvements that deliver improvements in potato tuber quality to industry and consumers may be easier to achieve if new varieties are bred for production at the regional level. Technical Abstract: The dry matter content of potatoes used to make potato chips and French fries strongly influences fry oil absorption and texture of the finished product. Specific gravity (SpGr) is often used to assess the processing quality of potatoes tubers because of its strong correlation with dry matter content and ease of measurement. . For French fry processing varieties, the desirable range for mean SpGr is 1.080–1.095 and a small variance around the mean is essential for product uniformity. The reliability of potato SpGr measurements was evaluated using potatoes from two multi-site, multi-year trials. Consistent with earlier studies, our data show that estimates of mean SpGr were highly repeatable: the median plot-basis value was 0.83 for a national trial with 6 locations and 3 years. In contrast, the median repeatability of the standard deviation between tubers was only 0.21. Thus, large multi-environment trials are required in order to identify varieties with a narrow SpGr distribution. Finlay-Wilkinson stability analysis of the mean, however, indicated that the SD of one potato variety was noticeably higher than the rest. When genotype BLUPs were regressed on the environment means, this variety had a regression coefficient of 2.1 compared to 0.4–1.4 for the other entries. The genetic correlation between environments showed a consistent regional pattern in mean specific gravity over time. There was a higher mean correlation between environments within the Pacific Northwest (0.97), Upper Midwest (0.91), and Northeast (0.85) than between environments from the different regions (0.35 to 0.78). Although breeding for national adaptation is an attractive idea, our results suggest that genetic gain may be easier to achieve at the regional level. |