Page Banner

United States Department of Agriculture

Agricultural Research Service


Location: Soil Management Research

Title: Comparative assessment of organic and conventional production of row crops under climate change: Empirical and simulated yield variation in the Chippewa River Watershed, MN

item Jaradat, Abdullah
item Starr, Jon
item Boody, George

Submitted to: Meeting Abstract
Publication Type: Abstract Only
Publication Acceptance Date: 3/1/2014
Publication Date: N/A
Citation: N/A

Interpretive Summary:

Technical Abstract: The long-term provision of ecosystem services, including stable temporal crop yields, provided by the traditional corn-soybean cropping system in the Chippewa River Watershed (CRW) in west-central Minnesota are being threatened by several anthropogenic and climatic factors. We conducted an empirical and simulated study to (1) provide an improved understanding of the role of projected global climate change (GCC) and its interaction with soil types, land use, and management practices on temporal yield variation of conventional (CNV) and organic (ORG) cropping systems, and (2) develop prediction models to scale up cumulative yield and its temporal variation from plot to watershed level and predict future impacts on agroecosystem services. We quantified the long-term ORG and CNV temporal yield variation of current and expanded, more diverse crop rotations under current (2002-2009), past and future 50-year climate change conditions using four GCC scenarios and five representative Mollisols in CRW. Results of the study suggested that (1) ORG can enhance a number of ecosystem services, but may have lower and more stable yields compared with CNV. (2) Cumulative yield of ORG crop rotations were improved and ranged from 80 to 90% of CNV by expanding crop rotations to include greater crop diversity, especially under projected GCC. (3) The largest portion of variation in cumulative yield and its temporal variation within each GCC scenario was attributed to differences between the five Mollisols, followed, in decreasing order by differences between ORG and CNV, crop rotations, and management practices. (4) Differences in management practices among ORG and CNV contributed differently to cumulative yield and its temporal variation depending on length and composition of crop rotations and soil types. (5) Temporal yield variation under current, past and future GCC in ORG was consistently less than CNV; however, both can be further reduced by inclusion of perennial crop and adopting improved management practices. (5) ORG farmers in CRW can diversify current cropping systems, enhance the buffering capacity of their land, and help mitigate the impact of GCC by reducing external inputs, and adjusting land-use to accommodate more perennials in future crop rotations. (6) Significant and positive effect of a perennial forage crop on cumulative yield and its temporal variation is anticipated by the 3rd to 4th year of its inclusion in a crop rotation that includes a small grain crop in addition to corn and soybean. (7) The combined empirical and simulated results provided guideline to develop multifunctional ORG production systems that can produce standard commodities, stabilize their temporal yields, and provide a wide range of other ecosystem services.

Last Modified: 10/19/2017
Footer Content Back to Top of Page