Soil, Water, and Air Resources Research Unit Site Logo
ARS Home About Us Helptop nav spacerContact Us En Espanoltop nav spacer
Printable VersionPrintable Version     E-mail this pageE-mail this page
Agricultural Research Service United States Department of Agriculture
Search
  Advanced Search
 
Programs and Projects
Subjects of Investigation
 

Research Project: MANAGEMENT OF AGRICULTURAL AND NATURAL RESOURCE SYSTEMS TO REDUCE ATMOSPHERIC EMISSIONS AND INCREASE RESILIENCE TO CLIMATE CHANGE

Location: Soil, Water, and Air Resources Research Unit

Title: Swine odor analyzed by both odor panels and chemical techniques

Authors

Submitted to: Journal of Environmental Quality
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal
Publication Acceptance Date: April 4, 2011
Publication Date: September 1, 2011
Citation: Trabue, S.L., Kerr, B.J., Bearson, B.L., Ziemer, C.J. 2011. Swine odor analyzed by both odor panels and chemical techniques. Journal of Environmental Quality. 40:1510-1520.

Interpretive Summary: Odor assessments from animal production facilities is challenging due to the nature of the compounds and limitations of sampling techniques. We determined that odor assessed by human panels is not recommended due to bias associated with sampling bags and great variability between different human panels. Chemical analysis of odors from animal production facilities needs to be assessed with caution primarily because of limitations associated with the odor sampling devices, analytical techniques and knowledge of odor threshold values for individual odor causing compounds. Future odor studies should focus on improving field sampling devices and odor threshold concentrations values since those areas have the greatest potential to improve our understanding and confidence in evaluating odors from animal production. The results described in this report provide information on measuring odor from swine operations that will be useful for growers, animal scientists, engineers, and regulatory officials.

Technical Abstract: The National Research Council identified odors as a significant animal emission at the local level, and highlighted the need for the development of standardized protocols for sampling and analysis. In this study, odorous air from swine manure was analyzed by both human panels and with analytical techniques. Odor analysis by human panels used dynamic dilution olfactometry (DDO), while chemical analysis used acid traps for ammonia, florescence for hydrogen sulfide (H2S), and thermal desorption (TDS) GC-MS for volatile organic compounds (VOC). In addition, GC-MS-O (olfactometry) was used for identifying key odorants. Odor was quantified for DDO using dilution thresholds, while chemical analysis used odor activity values (OAV). Odor samples analyzed by DDO were collected in 10 L Tedlar bags and analyzed within 24 hr using a dynamic dilution forced-choice olfactometer. The GC-O technique used for determining key odorants was GC-SNIFF. Odor results for DDO show there was significant differences between odor panels and considerable variability within odor panels for determining odor threshold values. Several key VOC odorants were lost or reduced in concentration by storage in Tedlar® bags, including both phenol and indole compounds. Only ammonia was significantly correlated to dilution thresholds. Chemical analysis showed that odor levels stabilized after Week 7 and H2S was the most dominate odor. Correlation of odorant concentration was closely associated with the origin of the odorant from the diet. Other key odorants determined by both chemical and GC-MS-O included indole compounds, phenol compounds, ammonia, and several volatile fatty acids (i.e., butanoic, 3-methylbutanoic, and pentanoic acids).

   

 
Project Team
Prueger, John
Sauer, Thomas - Tom
Hatfield, Jerry
Parkin, Timothy - Tim
Pfeiffer, Richard - Dick
Trabue, Steven
 
Publications
   Publications
 
Related National Programs
  Climate Change, Soils, and Emissions (212)
 
Related Projects
   DEVELOPMENT OF INSTRUMENTS FOR MEASUREMENT OF PARTICULATES AND GASES FROM AGRICULTURAL OPERATIONS
   EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF IMPROVED MANAGEMENT ON CORN-SOYBEAN PRODUCTION SYSTEMS
   EMISSION INVENTORIES OF PARTICULATE MATTER, AMMONIA, GREENHOUSE GASES, AND VOCS FROM CATTLE FEEDLOTS
   SEPARATING COMPONENTS OF EVAPOTRANSPIRATION TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY IN VINEYARD WATER MANAGEMENT
   EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF CHANGING CLIMATE ON FOOD SECURITY THROUGH GLOBAL AGRICULTURAL MODELS
   APPLICATION OF LIDAR TECHNOLOGY FOR MEASUREMENT OF EMISSION AND DISPERSION FROM AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS
   AGRICULTURAL SOIL EROSION AND CARBON CYCLE OBSERVATIONS: GAPS THREATEN CLIMATE MITIGATION POLICIES
   IMPLEMENTATION OF THE AGMIP PROGRAM FOR SOUTH ASIA AND SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
   MEASUREMENT OF SPRAY DRIFT USING A COMBINATION OF LIDAR AND MICROMETEOROLOGICAL METHODS
   FIELD SCALE ASSESSMENT OF FACTORS CONTROLLING CORN AND SOYBEAN PRODUCTION EFFICIENCY
   EVALUATION OF SPRAY DRIFT AND INTERCEPTION BY BIOBUFFERS USING MICROMETEOROLOGICAL AND LIDAR TECHNIQUES
   CONTRIBUTION OF WOODY VEGETATION TO ORGANIC MATTER CONTENT OF SOILS UNDER FOREST PLANTATIONS-ASSESSMENT FOR BIOENERGY PRODUCTION
   Great Plains Agroforestry: Evaluation of Bioenergy Feedstock and Carbon Sequestration as Potential Long-Term Revenue Streams to Diversity...
   Swine diet formulation and its effect on deep pit foaming
   ACCELERATED DEVELOPMENT OF COMMERCIAL HYDROTREATED RENEWABLE JET (HRJ) FUEL FROM REDESIGNED OILSEED FEEDSTOCK SUPPLY CHAINS
   Great Plains Agroforestry: Evaluation of Bioenergy Feedstock and Carbon Sequestration as Potential Long-term Revenue Streams to Diversify...
 
 
Last Modified: 05/25/2013
ARS Home | USDA.gov | Site Map | Policies and Links 
FOIA | Accessibility Statement | Privacy Policy | Nondiscrimination Statement | Information Quality | USA.gov | White House