Natural Products Utilization Research Site Logo
ARS Home About Us Helptop nav spacerContact Us En Espanoltop nav spacer
Printable VersionPrintable Version     E-mail this pageE-mail this page
Agricultural Research Service United States Department of Agriculture
Search
  Advanced Search
 
Programs and Projects
Subjects of Investigation
 

Research Project: DISCOVERY AND DEVELOPMENT OF NATURAL PRODUCT-BASED WEED MANAGEMENT METHODS

Location: Natural Products Utilization Research

Title: Why are there no new herbicide modes of action in recent years

Author

Submitted to: Pest Management Science
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal
Publication Acceptance Date: October 12, 2011
Publication Date: January 1, 2012
Citation: Duke, S.O. 2012. Why are there no new herbicide modes of action in recent years. Pest Management Science. 68:505-512.

Interpretive Summary: Herbicides with new modes of action are badly needed to manage evolution of resistance of weeds to existing herbicides. Yet, no major new mode of action has been introduced to the market place for about 20 years. There are probably several reasons for this. New potential products may have remained dormant due to concerns that glyphosate-resistant (GR) crops have reduced the market for a new herbicide. The capture of a large fraction of the herbicide market by glyphosate with GR crops led to significantly diminished herbicide discovery efforts. Some of the reduced herbicide discovery research was also due to company consolidations. There could be other economic concerns and/or problems with toxicology with some potential products also. Another problem might be that the best herbicide molecular target sites may have already been discovered. However, target sites that are not utilized, for which there are inhibitors that are highly effective at killing plants, suggests that this is not true. Results of modern methods of target site discovery (e.g., gene knock out methods) are mostly not public. These methods have limitations that are discussed. In summary, the reasons for a long dry period for new herbicide target sites are unclear, but several factors are probably involved. The economic stimulus to the herbicide industry caused by the evolution of herbicide-resistant weeds, especially GR weeds, may result in one or more new modes of action becoming available in the not too distant future.

Technical Abstract: Herbicides with new modes of action are badly needed to manage evolution of resistance of weeds to existing herbicides. Yet, no major new mode of action has been introduced to the market place for about 20 years. There are probably several reasons for this. New potential products may have remained dormant due to concerns that glyphosate-resistant (GR) crops have reduced the market for a new herbicide. The capture of a large fraction of the herbicide market by glyphosate with GR crops led to significantly diminished herbicide discovery efforts. Some of the reduced herbicide discovery research was also due to company consolidations. There could be other economic concerns and/or problems with toxicology with some potential products also. Another problem might be that the best herbicide molecular target sites may have already been discovered. However, target sites that are not utilized, for which there are inhibitors that are highly effective at killing plants, suggests that this is not true. Results of modern methods of target site discovery (e.g., gene knock out methods) are mostly not public. These methods have limitations that are discussed. In summary, the reasons for a long dry period for new herbicide target sites are unclear, but several factors are probably involved. The economic stimulus to the herbicide industry caused by the evolution of herbicide-resistant weeds, especially GR weeds, may result in one or more new modes of action becoming available in the not too distant future.

   

 
Project Team
Duke, Stephen
Baerson, Scott
Pan, Zhiqiang - Peter
Dayan, Franck
 
Publications
   Publications
 
Related National Programs
  Crop Protection & Quarantine (304)
 
Related Projects
   DETERMINATION OF THE EFFECT OF GLYPHOSATE ON MINERAL CONTENT OF GLYPHOSATE-RESISTANT CROPS
 
 
Last Modified: 05/20/2013
ARS Home | USDA.gov | Site Map | Policies and Links 
FOIA | Accessibility Statement | Privacy Policy | Nondiscrimination Statement | Information Quality | USA.gov | White House