Out of the Lyme-Light
||Ticks aren't insects; they're acarines, closer kin to spiders. Unlike an insect's, a tick's head and body are one unit, resting entirely on eight legs. Even with so many legs, they can't get far without help from their hosts. It's a fact that ticks live where their hosts live. White-tailed deer are the keystone host for maintaining populations of the tick Ixodes scapularis. In the Northeast, this tick was initially described as the deer tick because it was first found on deer. Since then, scientists have shown that the deer tick is actually the blacklegged tick. In the Northeast, these ticks are notorious for transmitting the agent that causes human Lyme disease: Borrelia burgdorferi. They also transmit lesser known human diseases like ehrlichiosis and babesiosismicrobial infections characterized by flulike symptoms but much shorter-lived than Lyme disease.|
|Populations of blacklegged ticks are spreading to new locations each year. More than 10,000 human cases of Lyme disease are reported annually in the United States, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in Atlanta, Georgia. Lyme disease occurs mainly in suburban areas with an overabundance of deer. That's why USDA implemented a 5-year tick-control project in the Northeast in 1997. The project uses a device developed and patented by ARS scientists in Kerrville, Texas. The device, named the "four-poster," is being tested in four areas where the incidence of Lyme disease was among the highest in the country when the project startedOld Lyme, Connecticut; Bedford, New York; Colts Neck, New Jersey; and Narragansett, Rhode Islandand also at the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center (BARC) in Maryland. With a goal of reducing 90 percent of the nymphs, the researchers set out 25 four-posters at each of the five 1,280-acre treatment sites.|
|Safety First "People and deer will be able to live together without fear of Lyme disease," says ARS entomologist J. Mathews Pound. Pound is optimistic because he, ARS agricultural engineer J. Allen Miller, and ARS biological technician Craig LeMeilleur at the Knipling-Bushland U.S. Livestock Insects Research Laboratory in Kerrville invented the four-poster as an alternative to eliminating deer populations or applying chemical sprays to the environment. The four-poster consists of a bin filled with whole-kernel corn. "On the four corners of the bin are paint rollers, which hold one of the safest acaricides we could findamitraz," says Pound. The corn lures deer to the feeding station, where they brush up against the paint rollers. The acaricide rubs off and kills ticks on the animal's head and neck, where 90 percent of adult ticks are found. As the animal grooms itself, the acaricide is spread to other areas of the body.|
|Amitraz targets ticks and mites without harming beneficial insects. It is currently approved for use on livestock, so the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) granted the researchers special permission to use it on white-tailed deer during the 5-year project. "Choosing amitraz helped us gain public acceptance of the project. Even during hunting seasonfrom October through December, which also coincides with the time most adult blacklegged ticks feed on deeramitraz is considered safe. "Currently, no pesticide is approved for use on white-tailed deer. But this situation may soon change. The technology and its implementation are reminiscent of the chicken-or-the-egg story. No one was willing to try to get a pesticide approved for white-tailed deer until there was an application device. Vice versa, no one can make good use of the applicator without an approved pesticide," says Pound.|
|Knowing a Good Thing When You See It "When I found out about the four-poster, I immediately started the licensing process," says David Weld, executive director of the American Lyme Disease Foundation, which is forming a subsidiary company to market the four-posters. Concurrently, Y-Tex Corporation, an animal health company in Cody, Wyoming, began seeking EPA approval to register one of its products containing the insecticide permethrin for use on white-tailed deer. The Y-Tex product, Brute, is made and sold commercially for killing ticks on cattle and swine. In a separate study from 1996 to 1998, NASA researcher Vickie Solberg reported using several four-posters in a secured area at the Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Maryland. Her control site was the Patuxent Wildlife Research Center in Laurel, Maryland. By the second year, she says, "we saw 98 percent control of nymphs and 100 percent control of adult ticks using the four-posters with permethrin. So we know the chemical works." Permethrin is already known by many consumers as an ingredient in head lice shampoos for children.|
|Previous ARS trials with the four-poster proved its ability to kill and reduce populations of another tick, the lone star tick, Amblyomma americanum, in Texas. But when the researchers in the Northeast used the same methods, they found some surprising differences between Texas deer and northeastern deer. "Deer in the Northeast are more numerous, are larger, and have bigger appetites and thicker haircoats. So the first reality check was that we had to use lots more corn and more pesticide," says Pound. "Deer are as attracted to whole-kernel corn as children are to chocolate candy," says Pound. But, the researchers at four of the Northeast treatment sitesto varying degrees and in different yearsencountered competition from the number of acorns dropping from trees in the fall. "The deer ate the acorns instead of the corn in our feeders. It was certainly something we hadn't expected," he explains.|
| Life Cycles
In the Northeast, I. scapularis has a 2-year life cycle. Larvae become
infected during their first summer, when they feed on white-footed mice and
other small mammals and birds, which are reservoirs for the spirochete B.
burgdorferi. Nymphsthe stage after larvaesurvive winter and
spread B. burgdorferi the following spring and summer. By their second
fall, nymphs have turned into adult ticks, and the females begin seeking a host
that offers a large blood meal, most often the large population of white-tailed
"If there are fewer adult ticks to reproduce, we can expect fewer larvae
in the spring. Infected nymphs, smaller than a pinhead, transmit the most cases
of Lyme disease because their presence can go unnoticed until the infection is
established and because they are biting in the summer when people are outside
in shorts and T-shirts," says Pound.
Ticked Off in Maryland
The spring of 1998 was a busy time for ARS entomologist John F. Carroll,
technicians Kenneth W. Young and Eliseo N. Miramontes, and others at BARC.
That's when they set out four-posters at BARC and at two other locations in the
Baltimore-Washington areaLoch Raven and Gibson Island, Maryland. The
devices were placed along trails and in areas where deer congregate.
On fall and spring days, and on winter days when the temperature stays above 45
°F, the researchers spend their time stocking the feeders with corn and
applying acaricide to the rollers. "That's when adult blacklegged ticks
look for a blood meal," explains Carroll, "and nearly all female
ticks feed on deer."
Carroll says they are targeting female adults to prevent them from laying eggs.
"A female tick can lay up to 3,000 eggs in her lifetime," says
In the third year of treatment in Maryland, Carroll says, "it looks like
we're having an effectbut not yet at the level we had anticipated."
At the Loch Raven site, numbers of blacklegged tick nymphs were 71 percent
lower in treated areas in 2000 than in 1998. Reductions were nearly as good at
BARC68 percent. And they were promising on Gibson Island59
percentthe last site to go into operation.
Reductions of lone star tick nymphs were similar. The Maryland and New Jersey
sites are the only project sites to have deer that play host to the lone star
tick, which transmits a bacterium that causes human monocytic ehrlichiosis.
"If during 2 or 3 years, you can reduce nymph numbers by half, after 4 years you can reasonably expect to reduce them by 75 percent or more," says Carroll. To calculate the level of control, he uses a mathematical formula that accounts for the natural rise and fall of tick populations in any given season, depending on weather and other factors. Thanks to the American Lyme Disease Foundation, Lyme disease has become a household word. Although there is currently one Lyme disease vaccine on the market, its effectiveness hasn't been established for total disease prevention. For more information about Lyme disease, see the Foundation's web site at http://www.aldf.com. "In terms of having an impact on Lyme disease risk over a community-based area, the four-poster is the only current technology I know of that can do the job," says Pound. "I believe we are having an impact on tick populations in the Northeast, and there's still time to reach our goal."By Linda McGraw, and Judy McBride, Agricultural Research Service Information Staff. This research is part of Arthropod Pests of Animals and Humans, an ARS National Program (#104) described on the World Wide Web at http://www.nps.ars.usda.gov.
To reach scientists mentioned in this article, contact Linda McGraw, phone (309) 681-6530, or Judy McBride, phone (301) 504-1628.
"Out of the Lyme-Light" was published in the May 2001 issue of Agricultural Research magazine.