| The vine continued from its epicenter
near Brooksville to the north and southshowing that it could withstand
ecological conditions ranging from tropical to temperate. Over the past
7 years, it has been reported throughout Florida, from Tampa north to
the panhandle. Skunk vine was also found in North and South Carolina and
Georgia in the late 1990s and recently in Texas and Louisiana.
In a 1999 study by the University of Florida-Gainesville's
Center for Aquatic and Invasive Plants, the estimated cost of manually
removing skunk vine from a moderately infested area was $4,006 per acre
(or $1,622/hectare). Cost estimates for herbicide applications to a
moderate infestation (33.6 vines per square meter) was $1,593 per acre
($645/ha). To make matters worse, either method damages the valued vegetation
that the vine infested, and neither treatment gives complete control.
Enlisting Foreign Recruits
This past summer, Pemberton focused on the plant's native range in
Japan and Nepal as possible sources of insect biological control agents
that might curb P. foetida in Florida and Hawaii.
In June 2002, Pemberton and Pratt traveled to the island of Kyushu
in Japan to work for 10 days with entomologists from Kyushu University,
conducting surveys to see what insects feed on skunk vine. That same
month, they surveyed skunk vine for 2 weeks in and around Tokyo with
the help of entomologists from Tokyo Metropolitan University.
Pemberton and Min Rayamajhi, an ARS plant pathologist in the Invasive
Plant Research Laboratory, went to Nepal to conduct additional surveys
for natural enemies of skunk vine in the Kathmandu Valley for 3 weeks
in August 2002. While in Nepal they discovered an iridescent chrysomelid
leaf beetle that feeds on the leaves of skunk vine both as a larva and
an adult and appears to be related to the chrysomelid beetle that successfully
controlled klamath weed (St. John's wort), Hypericum perforatum,
during the 1950s and 1960s.
Two sawfly species were also found in Nepal, both of which feed on
the skunk vine leaveslining up side by side on a leaf, companionably
eating it together. Pemberton and Pratt also found a stem gall-maker,
a moth in the family Sessiidae that forms spindle-shaped galls up to
1 inch in diameter on skunk vine stems.
Despite the exotic locales, "These trips are hardly a vacation,"
says Pemberton, who is mainly responsible for the foreign exploration.
"We're very busy."
During surveys, Pemberton and Pratt set up cultures of insects collected
during the day and tended them at night to evaluate feeding habits.
The scientists also reared immature insects to adulthood so they could
be identified. (Immature insects can be extremely difficult to identify.)
They do some of this work at the universities they visit. At other times,
they use their hotel rooms.
"It definitely is stinky," says Pemberton of the skunk vine.
"If you have cultures you're working on, your hotel room starts
to smell. If you're in the hotel business, don't let field biologists
stay. You don't know what they'll bring in," he jokes.
What the two scientists brought back to the United States is hope,
in the form of one high-priority candidate biological control agent
to combat P. foetidathe flea beetle. They also brought
back a lace bug worth evaluation, and many other natural enemies were
discovered during the surveys that may be considered for testing and
Of all the critters, it's the flea beetle, Trachyaphthona sordida,
that looks the most promising. These small beetles have big hind legs
and readily hop and jump, which is how they got the name "flea
beetle." Pemberton and Pratt were fortunate to collect them while
in Kyushu. The beetles had not been collected for more than 40 years
and appeared to be present as adults for only a short period during
the early summer.
"One important aspect of flea beetle larvae is that they feed
on, or 'mine,' P. foetida roots," says Pratt, who is working
mainly on release and establishment of potential biocontrol insects.
Their consumption of the roots and root hairs limits the vine's ability
to absorb water and nutrients. This might cause the plant to die during
the dry season.
The team captured three batches of 200 beetles in 2 weeks and shipped
them to a quarantine laboratory at the Hawaiian Department of Agriculture,
in Honolulu. Scientists there, led by biological control section chief
Ken Teramoto, have agreed to collaborate with the ARS scientists by
conducting host-specificity testing. A new, state-of-the art quarantine
facility is under construction at the Invasive Plant Research Laboratory
and will be completed early this year. This facility will enable ARS
scientists to conduct more host-specificity testing in Florida. The
scientists have previously tested the psyllid in Gainesville and in
Hawaii and Australia.
Testing at the Hawaiian lab will determine what plants the insects
tend to feed and develop on to assess potential risks from their use.
This flea beetle has been recorded to feed only on skunk vine. Flea
beetles are usually very narrow specialists, using only a few species
in a group. Since T. sordida is an apparent specialist, and because
neither Hawaii nor the continental United States has any economic or
native plants that are closely related to skunk vine, the flea beetle
or other skunk vine biological control agents pose virtually no risk
to agriculture or our native ecosystems.
But before any insect can be released for biocontrol of skunk vine,
the new agent must be tested and scrutinized by committees of federal
and state scientists, an environmental assessment must be written, and
finally a release permit from the USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection
Service can be issued.
Another insect taken from Japan and placed into quarantine at the Hawaiian
lab is a lace bug, Dulinius conchatus, that originated in India.
The insect was accidentally introduced in the early 1990s into Japan,
where Pemberton and Pratt collected it.
The lace bug was found to damage skunk vine in the area surrounding
the old Osaka airport. Pemberton learned about both the lace bug and
the flea beetle in Japanese scientific literature, which he obtained
during a 1997 feasibility study of biological control of skunk vine
Natural enemies discovered for skunk vine are likely to prove useful
against sewer vine, Paederia cruddasiana, a related weed that
is becoming a problem in the Miami area.
"We hope that these biocontrol agents can suppress P. foetida
sufficiently for the plant to become a minor part of the flora,"
Pemberton agrees, and adds, "We want to keep its density low enough
that it ceases to be a problemno longer a dominant plant and unable
to cause any further ecological damage."By Alfredo
Flores, Agricultural Research Service Information Staff.
This research is part of Crop Protection and Quarantine, an ARS
National Program (#304) described on the World Wide Web at www.nps.ars.usda.gov.
Robert W. Pemberton and Paul
D. Pratt are with the USDA-ARS Invasive
Plant Research Laboratory, 3205 College Ave., Fort Lauderdale, FL
33314; phone (954) 475-0541, fax (954) 476-9169.
"Scouring the World for a Skunk Vine Control" was
published in the October
2003 issue of Agricultural Research magazine.