Stopping the Coffee
Berry Borer From
Boring Into Profits
Technician Ann Sidor examines
a liquid culture of fungal
endophytes isolated from
coffee plants. After harvesting
and freeze-drying of the fungal
mass, DNA will be extracted
for molecular identification.
Water may be the essential liquid for Earth's life forms, but coffee
really gets the body's motor going! Each day, millions stagger to the
kitchen coffee pot or local coffee joint for the morning pick-me-up.
But a tiny insect, the coffee berry borer (Hypothenemus hampei),
is threatening the crop. Though it isn't the only pest of the coffee
plant, it does the most damageabout $500 million worth.
Agricultural Research Service
entomologist Fernando E. Vega is investigating ways to stop the coffee
berry borer from eating holes into coffee beans, reducing the income
for coffee growers as well as lowering the quality of coffee crops around
the world. Vega is not only a coffee researcher, but also a coffee fan
who collects beans during vacations and roasts the precious commodity
Postdoctoral scientist Francisco
Posada injects the stem of a
coffee seedling with a
Beauveria bassiana spore
suspension. The fungus attacks
a wide range of insects,
including the coffee berry borer.
The Life of the Coffee Berry Borer
The coffee berry borer, or CBB, has an interesting life cycle. The
tiny (1.5-mm) bark beetle spends its entire larval life inside the coffee
berry, which encases the seed, commonly known as the coffee bean. Males
mate inside the berry with females, but never emerge. Only mated females
emerge to fly to a new berry and bore into it to lay eggs and start
the cycle anew. Only while outside the berry are the adult female borers
vulnerable to predators or chemical controls.
"Living most of its life inside the berry makes this pest difficult
to control with traditional chemical and biological controls, so other
methods must be devised," says Vega, who is with the Insect Biocontrol
Laboratory in Beltsville, Maryland. A commonly used insecticide, endosulfan,
is largely being abandoned due to its high toxicity to humans and the
insect's becoming resistant to it.
Every coffee drinker knows too much of the caffeine-laden beverage
will lead to the jitters. But does caffeine do the same thing to the
CBB? "Caffeine is toxic to many insects, but not so for the coffee
berry borer," says Vega. "Why this insect is immune to caffeine
is one of the areas we are studying."
To better understand fungal
endophyte diversity in coffee,
entomologist Fernando E. Vega
examines a fungal and bacterial
endophyte isolated from a
How They Do Their Damage
CBBs cause damage by boring and depositing eggs into the berry. Larvae
hatch and feed on the seed or bean, destroying it. Worldwide, the coffee
berry borer causes an estimated $500 million in losses. The coffee industry
has an economic value exceeding $70 billion annually, with over 20 million
coffee-farming families producing coffee in more than 50 countries.
"The insect can cause coffee farmers to lose up to 20 percent
of a crop and reduce the price by 30 to 40 percent," says Ted Lingle,
executive director of the Specialty Coffee Association of America. "Damage
from the borer hurts every coffee-producing country in the world."
Overall, the price of coffee beans is around 60 cents per pound, not
enough to cover production costs in most countries. This low price is
due to overproduction. But, if coffee is overproduced, why worry about
the coffee berry borer?
Adult female coffee berry
borer (Hypothenemus hampei) on
a green coffee bean. Adult
females bore a hole in
coffee berries and lay
their eggs near the two
coffee beans found inside
the berry. Once the eggs
hatch, the larvae feed on
the beans, rendering them
unsuitable for commerce or
greatly lowering their quality.
"It's important to protect the economic viability to grow the
crop; there are millions of people throughout the world who depend on
coffee production for their subsistence," says Vega.
In the United States, however, coffee prices range from about $2 per
pound to more than $30. Why the discrepancy? Hawaiian coffee, particularly
Kona coffee, which sells for about $35 a pound, is considered a specialty
coffee, which commands a much higher price for growers. This makes it
a commodity that must be protected from coffee berry borer damage. Specialty
coffees, grown under stringent conditions for better quality, are gaining
market share and becoming a more important U.S. commodity.
Fighting Back With Fungi
A fungus, Beauveria bassiana, attacks a wide range of insects,
including CBB. The challenge is to get the fungus in contact with the
insect pest. Vega and Francisco Posada, a postdoctoral scientist in
his laboratory, found the fungus can become endophyticmeaning,
once introduced to the plant, it integrates with plant tissues. "We
use four methods to place fungus: injecting it into the stem, spraying
it on the leaves, soaking seeds in it, and drenching soil with it,"
says Vega. "The idea is to make the fungus thrive in the plant
so that the coffee berry borer can become exposed to it." Vega
and Posada have shown that each method integrates fungus into plant
Scanning electron micrograph
of coffee berry borer.
| Together with colleagues in Mexico,
Vega is also investigating nematodes in the genus Metaparasitylenchus
to control CBB. Nematodes are microscopic simple worms. During a 2002
collaborative study with Alfredo Castillo, Francisco Infante, and Juan
B. Barrera of El Colegio de la Frontera Sur in Mexico and Lynn Carta in
the ARS Nematology Laboratory in Beltsville, Maryland, Vega and his colleagues
found that when female nematodes parasitized female coffee berry borers,
the result was not death, but reduction in reproductive efficiency. "Nonparasitized
insects laid an average of 10 eggs, but parasitized borers laid just under
2 eggs on average," says Vega.
As for why the borer is able to withstand caffeine's toxic effects,
there are some yeasts that detoxify chemicals, creating an edible food
source for insects. Vega, Michael Blackburn at the Insect Biocontrol
Laboratory, and Cletus Kurtzman in the Microbial Genomics and Bioprocessing
Research Unit and Patrick Dowd in the Crop Bioprotection Research Unit
in Peoria, Illinois, conducted a study to determine whether yeasts found
in CBB could detoxify caffeine. "We found that one of these yeasts,
Pichia burtonii, does not appear to be associated with caffeine
degradation and may produce enzymes involved in providing nutritional
factors for the insect," says Vega. "Further research is necessary
to determine the role of yeasts in CBB biology."
Vega is looking at CBB not in isolation, but as part of the ecosystem.
"There are innumerable interactions among the insect, the microorganisms
it harbors, and the coffee plants. We need to understand those interactions
to help alleviate the damage caused by this pest," says Vega.By
Agricultural Research Service Information Staff.
This research is part of Crop Protection and Quarantine, an ARS
National Program (#304) described on the World Wide Web at www.nps.ars.usda.gov.
Fernando E. Vega is with
the USDA-ARS Insect
Biocontrol Laboratory, 10300 Baltimore Ave., Bldg. 011A, Rm. 214,
Beltsville, MD; phone (301) 504-5101, fax (301) 504-5104.
"Stopping the Coffee Berry Borer From Boring Into Profits"
was published in the November
2004 issue of Agricultural Research magazine.