Vitamin D Research: Humans May Benefit From Animal Health Studies
Jersey cows at the National
Animal Disease Center, Ames,
Research on how vitamin D can help fight a cattle disease
seems to have paid off in recent gains in both beef quality and human
In the latter case, a metabolite of vitamin D's least
toxic form, vitamin D2, is being examined as a potential
cancer fighter. In the other, the vitamin's toxic characteristics are
being used to tenderize beef.
Both developments can be traced to ARS
physiologist Ronald Horst, who for 25 years has studied various vitamins'
disease-fighting qualities. He heads the Periparturient Diseases of
Cattle Research Unit, part of the National Animal Disease Center in
Shortly after arriving at Ames in the late 1970s, Horst saw that vitamin D's crucial role in calcium production warranted attention as a possible way to prevent hypocalcemia, or milk fever, in dairy cows. The disease afflicts animals as they produce colostrum, or mothers' first milk. They cannot replace the great quantities of calcium lost in the process.
Physiologist Ronald Horst
prepares a tray of cow
plasma extracts to be
analyzed for vitamin D by
"This causes them to lose nerve and muscle function,
including the ability to stand," Horst says. "They eventually
lapse into a coma if not treated." Horst says milk fever affects
6 to 8 percent of all U.S. dairy cows and costs $210 million in losses
Vitamin D3the form found in humans and
other animalscan prove toxic if too much is given. But, says Horst,
"We knew from previous work that high levels of vitamin D2
could prevent milk fever." So Horst further examined how the less
toxic vitamin D2 worked to prevent the bovine illness. Found
mainly in plants, vitamin D2 is used as a dietary supplement.
"We looked at the blood to see what metabolites were
being produced as a result of its consumption. We noticed some metabolites
that had not been previously identified," he says. Among them was
an active metabolite known as 1,24-dihydroxyvitamin D2. "By
active, we mean it was enhancing calcium absorption and bone calcium
resorption," says Horst. That active metabolite became the focus
of his studies.
Physiologist Ronald Horst collects
blood from a Jersey cow to analyze
her vitamin D and calcium status.
Prevents Growth of Cancer Cells...
For vitamin D to help build strong, healthy bones and
teeth, it must be activated, usually into a form, or metabolite, called
1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D2. But the discovery of 1,24-dihydroxyvitamin
D2 represents a new pathway for vitamin D2 activation.
Both 1,24-dihydroxyvitamin D2 and 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin
D2 act in the intestine and kidney to raise blood calcium.
Without vitamin D, bones can become thin, brittle, soft, or misshapen.
If this vitamin D activation system breaks down, metabolic diseases
such as milk fever in dairy cattle and osteoporosis in people can flourish.
In Horst's early studies, 1,24-dihydroxyvitamin D2despite showing promise as a less toxic form of vitamin D for replenishing lost calcium in cattleproved problematic. "It was hard to produce, very expensive, and created some unwanted side effects," says Horst. "As a result, we moved on to other things."
Technician Duane Zimmerman
analyzes plasma samples from
cows for calcium concentration
with an atomic absorption
But a few years later, a private pharmaceutical firm began taking a good, long look at 1,24-dihydroxyvitamin D2 for potential benefits to human health.
Various independent studies have suggested that vitamin
D can treat or prevent cancer. "It prevents growth of cancer cells,"
says Horst. But its toxicity hampered this research.
Excessive intake of vitamin D can lead to anorexia, nausea,
vomiting, weakness, nervousness, and impaired renal function, as well
as calcification of blood vessels and kidneys. That is why 1,24-dihydroxyvitamin
D2 was attractive to researchers.
"It has a good safety profile," says Joyce Knutson,
director of preclinical research at Bone Care International, Inc., based
in Madison, Wisconsin. "When you are using a form of vitamin D
to fight cancer, you don't want its elevating effect on calcium to create
She says LR-103, which is 1,24-dihydroxyvitamin D2's pharmaceutical name, will enter clinical trials for its effect on a variety of cancers before year's end. Bone Care and ARS share a patent on the drug.
...And It Tenderizes Meat
Vitamin D's toxicity was used in a positive way in studies conducted
with Iowa State University in Ames, which were led by Donald Beitz,
a professor of animal science and biochemistry. This research is now
being evaluated within the U.S. beef industry.
"We took advantage of the potential toxic effect of vitamin D,
and of vitamin D3 in particular," says Horst. The result:
a new way to tenderize beef.
Horst explains that if animals receive too much vitamin D, their blood
calcium levels can rise to 40 to 50 percent above normal. "If blood
calcium remains at these concentrations for several days, animals can
become sick and eventually die," he says. "But most mammals
can tolerate an increase in blood calcium of 20 to 30 percent for 3
to 5 days without any harm.
"Creating that 20- to 30-percent elevation in blood calcium by
feeding excess vitamin D3 2 to 3 days before slaughter results
in greater muscle calcium and more tender cuts of meat," he says.
"Elevated calcium in the meat activates postmortem muscle enzymes
that can help degrade structural proteins responsible for tough meat."
He says the method triggers no ill effect for consumers and has no
harmful effect on the animal, unless too much vitamin D3
is used. ARS and Iowa State University share a patent on this technique,
which is being tested by private firms. Interest has increased in the
past 2 years.
An identical method has been applied to pork. It has led to improved
meat color, but no tenderizing effect has been observed.By Luis
Pons, Agricultural Research Service Information Staff.
This research is part of Animal Health, an ARS National Program
(#103) described on the World Wide Web at www.nps.ars.usda.gov.
"Vitamin D Research: Humans May Benefit From Animal Health Studies" was published in the July 2003 issue of Agricultural Research magazine.