Fungus Unleashed To
Combat Yellow Starthistle
In a remote spot at Mead Ranch, in northern California's Napa Valley,
scientists are monitoring the health of yellow starthistle (YST)a
seemingly odd thing to do considering this spike-crowned weed is an
But the scientistsBill Bruckart, Dale Woods, and Mike Pitcairn-don't
want the thistle, Centaurea solstitialis, to flourish. Rather,
they're checking the effects of a rust fungus whose spores they sprayed
on the weed last summer as a natural, environmentally safe means of
Bruckart is a plant pathologist with USDA's Agricultural
Research Service. Woods, a plant pathologist, and Pitcairn, an entomologist,
are with the Biological Control Program of the California Department
of Food and Agriculture in Sacramento.
Herbicide spraying, mowing, and prescribed burning are some of the
methods landowners have used to fight YST, which arrived in the United
States in the mid-1800s, probably from southern Europe or the Caucasus
Region. Today, the invasive weed can be found in many of the 48 contiguous
states, with California being the most infested (more than 14 million
acres). Worse, YST continues to spread.
Three weeks after yellow
starthistle was inoculated
with rust spores, ARS plant
pathologist Bill Bruckart (left)
and California Department of
Food and Agriculture plant
pathologist Dale Woods inspect
one of 20 test sites to learn
about the pathogen's performance.
Like many other exotic plants now calling the United States home,
the weed thrives without the natural enemies it left behind. At Mead
Ranch, however, scientists arranged for a deadly reunion.
With approval from USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service
(APHIS), the State of California, and the Napa County Agricultural Commissioner,
the team chose the YST-infested ranch as the first release site for
Puccinia jaceae var. solstitialis, a rust species known
to attack the thistle in its native rangeMediterranean countries.
APHIS's approval of the rust caps 25 years of laboratory and field
research by Bruckart, his predecessor Robert Emge, and others to ascertain
the fungus's safety and potential as a biological control agent. Because
of the rust's exotic origins, the scientists conducted their work inside
a containment facility at ARS's Foreign Disease-Weed Science Research
Unit at Fort Detrick, Maryland.
Morning dew on a yellow
starthistle leaf. Evening
inoculations with rust spores
(from Puccinia jaceae var.
solstitialis) are made to
catch the overnight dew needed
for spore germination and
July 2003 marked the first outdoor release of the rust fungus.
The scientists see the rust as a self-spreading addition to augment
current weed-control options. Once the rust takes hold, it should weaken
YST's ecological grip on the land and flora. Low-traffic areas such
as pasture or rangelandrather than cultivated fields, orchards,
or vineyardsmay benefit most from the fungus's presence, says
Woods. Plus, treating such large land areas with herbicide can be costly
and potentially harmful to the environment.
Every few weeks, the research team visits the site to monitor for fungal
infection of the thistles, damage to the plants after attack, and the
rust's spread to new areas.
"We didn't anticipate that it would spread the first year, and
it hasn't," says Woods. "Right now, it's in its overwintering
stage. By March, we'll start to see it spreadjust a few meters
or so, then hopefully miles by the end of summer."
California Department of Food
and Agriculture plant pathologist
Dale Woods (left) and plant
pathologist Bill Bruckart find
small, rust-colored spots on
starthistle leaves, indicating
that the first field releases
of rust spores are a success.
| They're also closely monitoring
other plants, including a native thistle species, near the test plot.
But where YST grows, little else can compete. Woods estimates that 40
percent of the valley floor at Mead Ranch is YST-infested, with some grass
species still holding out against the weed.
One characteristic in the weed's favor is a root system able to tap water sources
at soil depths beyond the reach of other plants. Seed production is
another. Large plants can produce as many as 100,000 seeds, each sporting
barblike hairs that cling to a passing animal's fur or person's clothing.
Spines radiating out from beneath the plant's flower head discourage
But such defenses fail against YST rust fungus.
It attacks the thistle's leaves and stem, forming orange-brown lumps
called pustules. "These pustules rob YST of nutrients," Bruckart
says. "If the pustule number is great enough, root growth and seed
production will decrease."
Small, rust-colored spots
on starthistle leaves. The
presence of these spots
indicates that the first
field releases of rust spores
on starthistle are a success.
If such attacks stunt the thistle's growth, other plants will be more
likely to outcompete the weed for sunlight, nutrients, and water. "That,
in and of itself, is a successful control," Woods adds.
To make sure other plants don't suffer the same fungal fate as YST,
Bruckart conducted host-specificity studies inside a climate-controlled
greenhouse containment facility at ARS's Fort Detrick lab. There, he
inoculated 65 plant species, representing 10 families, so he could monitor
their responses to the fungus. Thirty-nine of those, including commercially
grown safflower, were chosen for their close relationship to the thistle.
Though some infection did occur on safflower, the plant suffered little
harm, reports Bruckart, who compared YST rust with P. carthami,
a naturalized rust that attacks U.S. safflower crops. His studies also
identified the combination of temperature and humidity at which the
YST rust grows best.
The researchers used this information to make an inoculum, or spore
preparation, of the fungus using YST plants grown in their greenhouse.
Woods harvests the spores three times a week with a vacuum harvester
and freezes them for later use.
California Department of Food
and Agriculture lab assistant
Viola Popescu uses a cyclone
spore collector developed at
the Fort Detrick lab to harvest
inoculum from plants at the
CDFA greenhouse in Sacramento.
Before releasing the fungus, the scientists had to furnish APHIS with
an environmental assessment. In deciding whether to grant a 1-year permit,
the regulatory agency also considered recommendations of the Technical
Advisory Group for Biological Control of Weeds, which represents federal,
state, and university interests. APHIS made the final decision on the
release and signed the necessary documentation. The scientists are now
awaiting approval extending the current permit for additional releases
of rust in California.
The fungus joins five other APHIS-approved biological control organisms
now established on YST. These include two exotic fly species and three
weevil species that diminish the weed's seed production.
At least three of these insects are known to occur at the Mead Ranch
site. Though their success against the weed has been mixed, "We're
hoping the rust will tip the balance," Bruckart says.
Biological control is a gradual process, so a decline in YST populations
may take several years. But once the rust secures a good choke hold,
it isn't likely to ease up.By Jan
Suszkiw, Agricultural Research Service Information Staff.
This research is part of Plant Diseases, an ARS National Program
(#304) described on the World Wide Web at www.nps.ars.usda.gov.
To reach scientists mentioned in this article, contact Jan
Suszkiw, USDA-ARS Information
Staff, 5601 Sunnyside Ave., Beltsville, MD 20705-5129; phone (301)
504-1630, fax (301) 504-1641.
"Fungus Unleashed To Combat Yellow Starthistle" was
published in the August
2004 issue of Agricultural Research magazine.