Hometop nav spacerAbout ARStop nav spacerHelptop nav spacerContact Ustop nav spacerEn Espanoltop nav spacer
Printable VersionPrintable Version     E-mail this pageE-mail this page
United States Department of Agriculture Agricultural Research Service
Search
 
 
 
National Programs
International Programs
Find Research Projects
The Research Enterprise
Office of Scientific Quality Review
OSQR Panel Reports
Project Plan Information
Project Plan Revision
Schedule of Peer Reviews
1000 Word Picture
Some Helpful Advice from an Area Director
Reviewer Information
Suggested Reviewer Form
Scientific Writing Resources
OSQR Presentations
Frequently Asked Questions from ARS Scientists about Intramural Peer Reviews
ARS Focus Group on Peer Review
OSQR Staff
Conflicts of Interest List
OSQR Handbook March 2011.pdf
Research Initiatives
 

Office of Scientific Quality Review (OSQR)

OSQR News!

Updated 5/12/2010

What are we required to list from a CRIS Search?

This question, or a version of it, comes up frequently.  There is no such section in a plan as "CRIS Search." Rather, this is a potential part of the section entitled "Related Research (see page 12 of the OSQR Handbook). As noted there, the purpose of this section is that it "...shows the relationship of the research to other efforts within and outside USDA." (emphasis added).  The point is to show reviewers how your work complements other work. With regard to items that are revealed by a CRIS search the point is to show that you are aware of this work and that you are not simply doing the same thing.  So good to show what that work is and how it differs or enhances the current work. The same is true if there is a large university-based or other project of which you are aware. Reviewers often see two or more projects that seemingly address the same thing and their logical questions are: "how do these differ?" or "why are they doing the same thing?" One of the goals of this section is to address that. So should you list a related project that will end before yours begins? If you think knowing about it provides reviewers with a clearer picture of how your work fits within the breadth of other similar work, you should. But the final decision is up to you.

Examples of Successful Plans

OSQR regularly receives requests for examples of plans which received high review scores. There are number of sources OSQR recommends for finding examples of high-scoring plans to use as guides ( click for full story…).

 

Postponement Guidelines

The Postponement Guidelines (Bulletin 07-601) have been replaced by Appendix 13: Postponement Guidelines in the new OSQR Handbook. This represents a change to the location of this information but not to present practices as the OSQR, in cooperation with Area PAs implemented the procedures described in Appendix 13 more than a year ago.

What is OSQR?

PROJECT PLANS

OSQR Handbook 
Project Plan Information, Format 
Conflicts of Interest List 
Project Plan Revision

IMPORTANT TO KNOW

Schedule of Peer Reviews 
Postponement Guidelines 
A 1,000 Word Picture 
Some Advice from an Area Director 

FOR REVIEWERS

Reviewer Information
Be a Peer Reviewer

RESOURCES

Scientific Writing Resources 
OSQR Presentations 
ARS Focus Group on Peer Review  OSQR Panel Reports
OSQR Staff


     
Last Modified: 10/28/2011
ARS Home | USDA.gov | Site Map | Policies and Links 
FOIA | Accessibility Statement | Privacy Policy | Nondiscrimination Statement | Information Quality | USA.gov | White House